The Family Jewels: Origins of the Document
Government Crimes Week begins with an institution asking its employees a question most employers would rather leave out of the annual survey: what have we done that might fall outside our legal authority? In May 1973, CIA director James Schlesinger demanded answers. The resulting collection became the “Family Jewels,” an internal inventory whose reassuring nickname did considerable work for an alarming set of papers.
The file
Watergate reaches the filing cabinets
The immediate pressure came from Watergate and its related disclosures. Former CIA officers E. Howard Hunt and James McCord connected the scandal to the agency's past personnel, while revelations about assistance to Hunt raised questions about what the CIA had supplied and what its leadership knew. The agency's involvement in support for the burglary of Daniel Ellsberg's psychiatrist's office intensified those concerns. These were related scandals, not all the same break-in.
On 9 May 1973, Schlesinger directed employees to report activities that “might be construed to be outside the legislative charter of this Agency.” His instruction reached backward as well as forward. He wanted questionable past activities and anything still occurring, not merely assurances that current paperwork was in order.
The distinction mattered. The National Security Act had denied the CIA police, subpoena, law-enforcement and internal-security functions. Domestic surveillance, detention and interference with Americans therefore raised questions different from ordinary foreign intelligence collection. Schlesinger was commissioning an internal accounting, however, not handing down criminal judgments on every item submitted.
Colby's skeletons, and several different lists
William Colby, then the agency's operations chief and subsequently Schlesinger's successor as director, oversaw the compilation and became central to its disclosure to investigators. Offices contributed memoranda and recollections. The familiar description is 693 pages; the National Security Archive's downloadable release contains 702 scanned pages. Those counts describe different packaging of the collection, not two separate scandals.
The often-mentioned eighteen-point “skeletons” list needs a date attached. A Justice Department memorandum by James Wilderotter, dated 3 January 1975, records Colby's briefing of Deputy Attorney General Laurence Silberman and Wilderotter on 31 December 1974. Colby paraphrased matters presenting legal questions; the memorandum records eighteen specifics. It is a contemporary record of his briefing, not an eighteen-item document personally authored by Colby in May 1973.
Its subjects included the confinement of Soviet defector Yuri Nosenko, wiretapping of columnists, surveillance of journalists, mail opening, assassination planning and files on Americans associated with the antiwar movement. The bureaucratic vocabulary did not make these minor administrative irregularities. It did identify what officials were discussing and where later investigators could look.
Hersh puts domestic spying on page one
On 22 December 1974, Seymour Hersh's New York Times investigation reported a large CIA domestic intelligence operation against antiwar activists and other Americans. That reporting publicly exposed major abuses associated with the Family Jewels; it was not publication of the complete internal binder. Describing it as “the leak” is useful shorthand only if that difference survives.
The revelations helped precipitate the Rockefeller Commission and congressional investigations, including the Church Committee, in 1975. Other disclosures and longstanding concerns also contributed. A single newspaper article did not independently create every subsequent safeguard, but it transformed the political conditions in which officials could demand records and testimony.
The documents themselves require critical reading. Some submissions relied partly on recollection, and an internal inventory could omit activities, soften descriptions or reflect what a particular office knew. It is powerful evidence of institutional knowledge and reporting, not a complete ledger of every secret operation or a substitute for legal findings.
The release still had blank spaces
On 26 June 2007, the CIA released the collection after decades of controversy and fifteen years after the National Security Archive's FOIA request. Much of the subject matter had already emerged through investigations. The new value lay in the underlying memoranda, their wording and the relationships between offices, rather than 693 entirely unfamiliar revelations.
NPR's contemporaneous reporting estimated that a full fifteen percent of the documents were completely whited out, with many others heavily edited. That is an estimate about the 2007 release, not a newly measured percentage of what remains secret today.
Item one in the Office of Security's original list was withheld, while its next item described the Roselli/Castro assassination operation. This is a different list from the eighteen-point Justice Department account, whose first item was Nosenko's confinement. The released file treats the missing Security entry as sensitive; it does not reveal its subject. Neither its position nor its redaction proves a particular imagined crime. This article cannot establish whether every withholding remains unchanged in 2026.
Our header is an editorial illustration, not a photograph of the original binder. The authentic document is linked below.
Why it was classified
The collection exposed covert operations, identities and activities with potential legal and political consequences. Classification and later FOIA withholding restricted access. Its DECLASSIFIED stamp records the 2007 release, not complete disclosure or a finding that every listed activity constituted a crime.
Why it matters
The Family Jewels show how institutional self-reporting became evidence for outside oversight. They also demonstrate why readers must distinguish a directive, an office's list, a legal briefing and a later public release instead of treating them as one perfectly complete confession.
Sources
Schlesinger directive, 9 May 1973 (primary document): https://nsarchive2.gwu.edu/NSAEBB/NSAEBB222/schlesinger_jewels.pdf
CIA Family Jewels, released 26 June 2007; Office of Security memorandum, 16 May 1973, opening pages (primary-document mirror): https://nsarchive2.gwu.edu/NSAEBB/NSAEBB222/family_jewels_full_ocr.pdf
James Wilderotter, CIA Matters, 3 January 1975, recording the 31 December 1974 briefing: https://nsarchive2.gwu.edu/NSAEBB/NSAEBB222/family_jewels_wilderotter.pdf
National Security Archive, CIA's Family Jewels, 21–26 June 2007; release history and contemporary documents: https://nsarchive2.gwu.edu/NSAEBB/NSAEBB222/index.htm
Seymour Hersh, New York Times, 22 December 1974, Huge C.I.A. Operation Reported in U.S. Against Antiwar Forces, Other Dissidents in Nixon Years: https://www.nytimes.com/1974/12/22/archives/huge-cia-operation-reported-in-us-against-antiwar-forces-other.html
Mary Louise Kelly, NPR, CIA Reports Describe Illegal Activity, 27 June 2007 (contemporary fifteen-percent estimate): https://www.npr.org/2007/06/27/11457406/cia-reports-describe-illegal-activity
Related files
Let Lovable AI search the released archive for files connected to this one — or paste another document you're reading.

